marginalium noun

the notes one makes in the margins.

A short note on

do feelings have a ‘hard problem’

August 28, 2023

source: dynomight.net

by Dorian Minors

I did brain science at Cambridge. Now I'm a behaviour science professor. Read my shit.

Do feelings have a ‘hard problem’?

Author recaps the hard problem of consciousness:

There seems to be no need for consciousness. Physics wouldn’t care if we were all “zombies”. Why aren’t we?

I like to look at it this way:

  1. We are alive.
  2. We are conscious.
  3. We were created by evolution.
  4. But consciousness can’t “do” anything.
  5. Huh?

Then makes the same claim about feelings:

Well, why do we have feelings? Consider this variant of our earlier puzzle.

  1. We are alive.
  2. We have feelings.
  3. We were created by evolution.
  4. We feel good when we do stuff that would help propagate the genes of someone in a hunter/gatherer band.
  5. But feelings can’t “do” anything.
  6. The hell?

Interesting, but I think this is a category error. Feelings are the natural extension of a nervous system and the equivalent in non-nervous animals.

One email a month: the new essays, lectures, and marginalia.
More where this came from. Get the newsletter.